Results for Top Rivalry 2012

Total Votes: 49,046
Baltimore City
Baltimore, Md.
Baltimore Poly
Baltimore, Md.

At the end of every practice, Poly players turn to face their rival school to the East and shout, "Beat City." The rivalry, which began in 1889, is believed to be the second-longest continual public school rivalry in the country. Poly and City met on Thanksgiving Day until 1993, when the game was moved to the final Saturday of the regular season.

Total Votes: 5,614
Dover, Del.
Caesar Rodney
Camden, Del.

This heated rivalry known as "The Civil War" has been fairly balanced over the years. The annual matchup between crosstown rivals was suspended for a period around 1950 due to fights associated with the game.

Total Votes: 17,972
Fordham Prep
Bronx, N.Y.
New York, N.Y.

The oldest rivalry in the state, this matchup dates back to 1893. The first game was played in the dark and ended in a tie. The two schools go head-to-head in an annual Turkey Bowl.

Total Votes: 6,584
Norwich Free Academy
Norwich, Conn.
New London
New London, Conn.

This rivalry is so popular it's the subject of Brian Girasoli's book entitled "The Norwich Free Academy v. New London Football Rivalry". Widely regarded as the oldest high school football rivalry in the nation, Norwich Free and New London have been doing battle since 1875. This matchup has all the drama that makes heated rivalries so intriguing, from vandalism by students to alleged biased officiating. In 1951, a huge brawl put the heated rivalry on ice for two years before it resumed.

Total Votes: 14,019
Parkersburg, W.Va.
Parkersburg South
Parkersburg, W.Va.

This crosstown rivalry dates back to 1967 and is considered by many to be the most heated rivalry in the state. Parkersburg leads the all-time series 33-13.

Do you have an inspirational coaching story to share? Let us know about your coach on our Facebook page for future contests and stories.
Total Votes: 219,470
Peddie School
Highstown, N.J.
Blair Academy
Blairstown, N.J.

These two teams have met every year since 1903, with the exception of one, due to a polio outbreak. The rivalry was so heated that in 1935 the headmasters of the two schools formed what is known as "The Peddie-Blair Agreement", which says, among other things, that no goal posts can be torn down and the losing team's fans must remain in the stands and sing their school song after the winning team has already left the field.

Total Votes: 7,688
Derry, N.H.
Londonderry, N.H.

The annual meeting between these two schools serves as the finale to a two-day competition in eight sports for the Mack Plaque. Pinkerton has won the Mack Plaque 11 straight years.

Total Votes: 15,343
St. John's College
Washington, DC
Washington, DC

This rivalry, which is considered the oldest between two Catholic schools, dates back to 1889 and was traditionally played on Thanksgiving.

Total Votes: 310,252
St. Johnsbury Academy
St. Johnsbury, Vt.
Lyndon Institute
Lyndon Center, Vt.

These teams have met 107 times since 1894 in a matchup known simply as The Game. St. Johnsbury holds a 58-43-6 advantage in the series.

Total Votes: 39,777
Thornton Academy
Saco, Maine
Biddeford, Maine

Separated by a bridge connecting their respective towns, the annual Thornton-Biddeford game is aptly known as the Battle of the Bridge. During the week of the game, cheerleaders from each school decorate their end of the bridge with school colors. Per tradition, the losing coach presents the "Battle of the Bridge" trophy to the winning school the next week. Thornton owns an all-time record of 55-40-9.

Is your basketball student section one of the best? Let us know about it. Email Suzanne Schwerer at and ask her to check it out in her SSS feature.
Total Votes: 4,728
Wellesley Hills, Mass.
Needham, Mass.

The Wellesley, Needham rivalry isn't as old as Thanksgiving, but it's not too far off. The teams have only missed seven games (four because of World War I) since kicking off the Thanksgiving tradition with a 4-0 Wellesley win in 1882. Wellesley owns a 59-57-9 all-time edge, but Needham has won two straight going into this year.

Total Votes: 381
West Warwick
West Warick, R.I.
Coventry, R.I.

The schools are less than eight miles apart, and the rivalry has upheld every Thanksgiving Day. This year marks the 51st matchup of the series, which West Warwick dominates with 39 victories. Coventry last added to its nine wins in 2004.

Total Votes: 5,652
William Penn Charter
Philadelphia, Pa.
Germantown Academy
Fort Washington, Pa.

This is the nation's longest uninterrupted rivalry among prep schools in high school football history. The annual game dates back to 1887 and is currently the main event in a daylong schedule of athletic events that also includes soccer, cross country and others. For each win, the school gets one point. When all the events are finished, the school with the most points wins the Competition Cup.